Skip to content
Why Plan Mode Is Dead: The Shift to Iterative AI Development Loops
Industry Insights 20 min read

Why Plan Mode Is Dead: The Shift to Iterative AI Development Loops

The author reflects on building Nuanced, a planning-centric AI coding tool, and explains why plan mode failed: models now handle ambiguity, AI-generated specs are unreadable, linear workflows hinder iteration, and the future lies in continuous understand-act-inspect loops rather than static planning documents.

ThinkInAI Community
ThinkInAI Community
ThinkInAI Community

Original article: https://www.aymannadeem.com/artificial/intelligence,/developer/tools/2026/09/24/plan-mode-is-dead.html

September 24, 2026

Earlier this year, the author believed planning would become the most critical step when developing software with AI. Convinced of this, they built and released Nuanced (https://www.nuanced.dev/), a desktop coding application founded on the observation that AI had fundamentally increased code generation speed and volume, but interaction interfaces had not kept pace.

Model speed and code generation capabilities raced ahead, leaving a horse-drawn carriage labeled "Interfaces" far behind.

Model speed and code generation race ahead of a horse-drawn carriage labeled "Interfaces."
Model speed and code generation race ahead of a horse-drawn carriage labeled "Interfaces."

Why I Built Nuanced

The product aimed to answer a question the author still considers important: when machines modify software systems faster than humans can review those changes, how do humans maintain a coherent mental model of the entire system?

Models can write thousands of lines of code in minutes, meaning developers haven't even had time to think clearly about what they're building or why before facing a heavy maintenance burden. This makes it hard to reason about system behavior and debug erroneous assumptions that solidify into code too early.

An overwhelmed developer surrounded by agent-generated code, plans, diffs, and files, with questions about decisions, assumptions, and who changed what.

An overwhelmed developer surrounded by agent-generated code, plans, diffs, and files, with questions about decisions, assumptions, and who changed what.
An overwhelmed developer surrounded by agent-generated code, plans, diffs, and files, with questions about decisions, assumptions, and who changed what.

The ease of generating code brings a stronger dopamine reward, yet masks the unavoidable work: figuring out why to build something, whether it's truly worth building, and rigorously evaluating product, design, and infrastructure decisions. The author often found themselves with a product before consciously making any product decisions. If architecture wasn't specified, the agent would fill gaps, even if its abstraction boundaries caused problems later. Misunderstandings about intended behavior and design propagated into multiple files beneath the chat surface and were easily overlooked. Digging into those obscure issues felt less efficient than getting the design right from the start.

A developer fishes from a boat labeled "chat" above submerged code files, assumptions, product decisions, API boundaries, intended behavior, and hidden dependencies.

A developer fishing from a boat labeled "chat" above submerged code files, assumptions, product decisions, API boundaries, intended behavior, and hidden dependencies.
A developer fishing from a boat labeled "chat" above submerged code files, assumptions, product decisions, API boundaries, intended behavior, and hidden dependencies.

This created a sense of mental disconnection, almost zombie-like, especially after coding apps like Conductor and Codex began supporting more parallel agents. It became harder to focus and deeply understand what was being done, and harder to verify generated results. There was no clear, explainable chain linking "user prompt → agent decision → code → product behavior." The author does not want to return to staring at lines of code; they find reasoning in natural language around ideas easier and more efficient, and want to confidently drive above the code without sacrificing understanding of how the system works.

Existing Plan Modes Aren't Collaborative Enough

While plan modes exist, there isn't the right abstraction for doing planning well. Using Claude Code CLI, Conductor, and the released Codex, the author found themselves carefully shaping and refining plans but without a clear place to continuously iterate on them. Before Codex's annotation feature, planning was done in chat, then parts copied into new messages to modify — a repetitive cut-and-paste workflow that made continuous reasoning laborious while tracking the current plan.

The author wanted a home for plans, to place them within the overall workflow, and to turn them from ephemeral text blocks that disappear into history into a living, continuously evolving document. They wanted plan mode as a first-class primitive guiding development, for several reasons:

Need to think about what to do next.

Need to ensure descriptions are accurate enough.

Need to understand what's been done.

Need to understand when something went wrong and why.

Building the Ideal Workflow

The author encoded their ideal workflow into Nuanced. Nuanced lets you create threads, each a chat conversation. You describe what to build; the system surfaces ambiguities and decisions needed, then together you finalize a persistent plan before implementation begins. Nuanced then executes the plan and ensures generated code matches requirements. The goal was an end-to-end pipeline from intent through implementation, review, and verification — a prosthesis for the human mind (or ADHD brain), not just another coding app: designed to guide so the user can continuously stay on top of progress.

Why I Was Wrong

The problem wasn't that the judgment of gaps in existing tools or the view of how the software development lifecycle (SDLC) is changing was completely wrong, but that the implementation didn't deliver the expected solution. Four reasons:

Conflated planning with specs.

Models got really good.

Nobody wants to read AI-generated text.

Separated planning from building in a destructive way.

Planning ≠ Specs

The first lesson: planning and specs are not the same. The author thought having a space to think things through before implementation was valuable, and preserving those thoughts in a large structured artifact would be valuable as the project evolved. Early users showed surprisingly little interest in that spec.

Models Got Really Good

As models better understand large codebases through context and memory, they excel at exploring repos and making reasonable assumptions. The need to explicitly instruct them to produce well-thought-out results has decreased dramatically. The author didn't initially anticipate competition between model capability and designing better interfaces for human thought, but that's what's happening: every additional decision a model can make independently and reliably is one fewer decision that needs to be presented to the user.

AI-Generated Text Is Painful to Read

Specs contained more information but didn't bring more clarity because they were long. They recorded important decisions but also included vast amounts of seemingly useful context — all AI-generated. AI-generated text has a distinctive cadence and over-structured quality that makes it hard to read; the author kept zoning out. After discovering this, they didn't abandon specs but built a "Spec Tour" feature to guide users through important parts. This added another layer of complexity, putting more text on screen competing for attention. If a shorter version must be generated to make the spec usable, what was the point of the full document?

We Split a Process That Should Be Continuous

The workflow was too linear, with sharp boundaries between stages:

Chat → Disambiguate by answering questions → Generate spec → Review spec → Revise spec → Approve → Implement → Review code

Developers tumbled down a waterfall of sequential steps. Real thinking doesn't happen that way; separating stages feels stiff and artificial. Usually you understand part of the problem, try something; the first result gives new insight, changes your mind, and you try another approach. Every step raises new questions. Planning and building intertwine, unfolding gradually more naturally than plan mode allows. Nuanced's interface forced users to "finish thinking" prematurely to start building. Once in implementation, going back to chat-based reasoning felt like moving backward. Going down the waterfall meant never returning upstream.

Codex today shows the boundary between planning and execution dissolving, the two merging into one. Early coding agents suited a workflow where humans did:

Plan → Approve → Execute

Back then, the cost of going in the wrong direction was much higher. As agents get better at understanding systems, they also get better at acting autonomously and testing their own work, and adjusting after inspecting results. This enables a different loop:

Understand → Act → Inspect → Clarify → Adjust → Act Again

This loop still contains plenty of planning, but that planning doesn't necessarily need to appear as a document called a "plan." The author's biggest mistake was turning the plan into a deliverable instead of designing a process that enhances human understanding. The old linear workflow moved from plan to approve to execute, leaving a confused human at a barrier. The new iterative workflow cycles through understand, act, inspect, clarify, adjust, and act again, with a happy human DJ at the center.

The old linear workflow moves from plan to approve to execute, leaving a confused human at a barrier. The new iterative workflow cycles through understand, act, inspect, clarify, adjust, and act again, with a happy human DJ at its center.
The old linear workflow moves from plan to approve to execute, leaving a confused human at a barrier. The new iterative workflow cycles through understand, act, inspect, clarify, adjust, and act again, with a happy human DJ at its center.

The Distinction Between Plan Mode and Build Mode Is Awkward

Nuanced offered plan mode (always generates a spec) and build mode (no forced spec, suitable for small tasks). The distinction was awkward: users had to first ask a meta-question — is this task worth planning? — and if so, remember to enable plan mode via button or shortcut. That judgment should be made by the AI based on existing context; remembering which mode to use added cognitive load. Realizing this, the author felt like the person in the "midwit" bell-curve meme: a clean chat interface that lets the system plan on demand rather than by default is actually pretty good.

"Midwit" bell-curve meme: characters at both ends say "chat threads are good," while the middle character says "you need a new planning interface to really think."

Midwit bell-curve meme: the characters at both ends say "chat threads are good," while the character in the middle says "you need a new planning interface to really think."
Midwit bell-curve meme: the characters at both ends say "chat threads are good," while the character in the middle says "you need a new planning interface to really think."

We Still Haven't Solved the Understanding Problem

Thinking about what to build, why it matters, and how to evaluate decisions remains critical. People need a coherent mental model of what's happening, but large amounts of AI-generated text are not the right interface for that. Working through decisions in chat feels more intuitive, but keeping that understanding in sync as the system evolves is still unsolved.

This problem gets harder as the number of agents grows from five to hundreds. Keeping up can't mean reading every conversation and prompting agents to explain every code change. Agents need to surface the fewest, most attention-worthy leverage points and provide enough context to make that attention count.

We still haven't solved how to help people stay informed when hundreds of increasingly capable agents modify a system simultaneously. The deeper problem remains: how humans understand systems, navigate complex information hierarchies, and wield powerful tools. Interfaces will evolve alongside the technology driving them, but the need to make complex things understandable will not change.

Humans and a robot mourn beside a gravestone labeled "Plan Mode, 2025–2026," with flowers, a laptop, a checklist, and a memorial wreath.

Humans and a robot mourn beside a gravestone labeled "Plan Mode, 2025–2026," with flowers, a laptop, a checklist, and a memorial wreath.
Humans and a robot mourn beside a gravestone labeled "Plan Mode, 2025–2026," with flowers, a laptop, a checklist, and a memorial wreath.
Original Source

Signed-in readers can open the original source through BestHub's protected redirect.

Sign in to view source
Republication Notice

This article has been distilled and summarized from source material, then republished for learning and reference. If you believe it infringes your rights, please contactadmin@besthub.devand we will review it promptly.

AI-assisted developmenthuman-AI collaborationplan-modeAI Coding Agentssoftware development workflowNuancediterative workflowproduct lessons
Reader feedback

How this landed with the community

Sign in to like

Rate this article

Was this worth your time?

Sign in to rate
Discussion

0 Comments

Thoughtful readers leave field notes, pushback, and hard-won operational detail here.