Skip to content
Why Beef Prices Surged 27% While Pork Hit a 10-Year Low: The Cobweb Cycle

Why Beef Prices Surged 27% While Pork Hit a 10-Year Low: The Cobweb Cycle

Beef prices rose nearly 27% despite minimal output decline because past low prices led farmers to cull breeding cows and rely on cheap imports, creating a supply gap that the cobweb model predicts will persist until 2028, while pork prices hit a decade low as sow reductions only affect supply after a 10-month lag.

Model Perspective
Model Perspective
Model Perspective

01 First Loan: Borrowing from Breeding Cows

When cattle prices were low in previous years, many farmers sold breeding cows to cut losses. Selling a cow added meat to the market immediately, depressing prices further, but also eliminated the calves that cow would have produced. A cow takes about 9.5 months from breeding to calving, and the calf needs another 18–24 months to reach market weight. Thus, a decision to retain fewer breeding cows only reduces market supply roughly 2.5 years later.

The cheap beef widely available in recent years partly consumed "next year's and the year after's cattle." That debt is now coming due. In the first three quarters of 2026, cattle slaughter fell 3.1% year‑on‑year, yet beef output dropped only 0.7%, indicating farmers are fattening cattle heavier and holding back sales — a clear sign of tight supply.

Figure 1 | A cow's timeline: from deciding to keep one more breeding cow to that cow's meat reaching the market takes about 2.5 years
Figure 1 | A cow's timeline: from deciding to keep one more breeding cow to that cow's meat reaching the market takes about 2.5 years

02 Second Loan: Borrowing from Imported Frozen Beef

About 30% of China's beef consumption relies on imports. In 2024 domestic production was 7.79 million tonnes while imports reached roughly 2.87 million tonnes. Many low‑price beef restaurants depended heavily on imported frozen beef.

Starting January 2026, China imposed a three‑year safeguard measure on beef imports: in‑quota tariffs remain unchanged, but out‑of‑quota volumes face additional duties. This policy effectively recalls the second "loan" of cheap imported beef.

03 Why a Small Supply Drop Causes a Large Price Jump

Beef demand is relatively inelastic — most consumers reduce consumption only slightly when prices rise, and restaurants rarely remove beef dishes entirely. Therefore, a modest supply shortfall requires a disproportionately large price increase to balance the market.

Rough calculation: if a 10% price rise cuts demand by 3% (illustrative), then a 27% price rise implies total supply must have fallen by 8–9 percentage points. Domestic output fell only 0.7%; the bulk of the gap must come from reduced imports. Full‑year 2026 import data are not yet published; this magnitude is inferred and will be verified when official figures are released.

04 Same Month, Pork Hits a 10‑Year Low

While beef rises, pork falls. On 9 November 2026, the price of outer‑three‑way live hogs reached 8.63 yuan/kg, a near‑decade low. The two markets follow the same biological‑economic model but with different cycle lengths.

Sows gestate for 114 days and piglets finish in about six months — a full cycle of roughly 10 months. Farmers began cutting sow herds heavily in Q2 2026; by end of Q3, breeding sow inventory was down 10.7% year‑on‑year. The resulting supply reduction will not appear until around Q2 2027.

Thus, today beef is repaying debts incurred 2–3 years ago, while pork is still digesting the surplus from a year ago.

05 When Will Prices Fall Again?

Combining the two loans yields the classic cobweb model (Ezekiel, 1938): current prices are determined by breeding decisions made three years earlier. Low prices discourage breeding; three years later supply shrinks and prices surge; high prices encourage expansion; three years later supply swells and prices fall again. The hog cycle completes in about one year; the cattle cycle takes nearly three years.

Figure 2 | Cobweb model: supply looks at prices three years ago, prices look at current supply, causing oscillations (schematic)
Figure 2 | Cobweb model: supply looks at prices three years ago, prices look at current supply, causing oscillations (schematic)

If restocking begins now, additional beef will not reach the market until around 2028. Large ranches hedge using futures and policy signals, dampening the amplitude but not reversing the direction.

Next time an agricultural product becomes suspiciously cheap, ask: is this a genuine surplus, or is it borrowed from the future?

References National Bureau of Statistics. Agricultural Economy Situation for First Three Quarters of 2026 (cattle slaughter 34.55 million head, ‑3.1% YoY; beef output 5.46 million tonnes, ‑0.7% YoY). 19 Oct 2026. Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs monitoring: national wholesale market average beef price 73.65 yuan/kg (9 Nov 2026). Xinhua News Agency. China Implements Three‑Year Safeguard Measures on Imported Beef from 2026. 31 Dec 2025. Guanyan Tianxia. China's 2024 beef output 7.79 million tonnes, imports ~2.87 million tonnes. Yicai Global. Live Hog Price Hits Near‑Decade Low (outer‑three‑way 8.63 yuan/kg, 9 Nov 2026; breeding sows 36.02 million head at end‑Q3, ‑10.7% YoY). Nov 2026. Ezekiel M. The Cobweb Theorem. Quarterly Journal of Economics , 1938, 52(2): 255–280.

Code example

[1] 国家统计局. 2026年前三季度农业经济形势(肉牛出栏 3455 万头,同比下降 3.1%;牛肉产量 546 万吨,下降 0.7%). 2026-10-19.
[2] 农业农村部监测:全国农产品批发市场牛肉平均价格 73.65 元/公斤(2026-11-09).
[3] 新华网. 我国2026年起对进口牛肉采取为期3年的保障措施. 2025-12-31.
[4] 观研天下. 2024年我国牛肉产量 779 万吨、进口约 287 万吨.
[5] 第一财经. 生猪价格创近十年新低(外三元生猪 8.63 元/公斤,2026-11-09;能繁母猪三季度末 3602 万头,同比下降 10.7%). 2026-11.
[6] Ezekiel M. The Cobweb Theorem.
Original Source

Signed-in readers can open the original source through BestHub's protected redirect.

Sign in to view source
Republication Notice

This article has been distilled and summarized from source material, then republished for learning and reference. If you believe it infringes your rights, please contactadmin@besthub.devand we will review it promptly.

China marketagricultural economicsbeef pricescobweb modelimport safeguardslivestock cyclespork pricessupply lag
Reader feedback

How this landed with the community

Sign in to like

Rate this article

Was this worth your time?

Sign in to rate
Discussion

0 Comments

Thoughtful readers leave field notes, pushback, and hard-won operational detail here.